It was practically a side note that there was a launch three days before Christmas of the Japanese H3 rocket carrying a navigation satellite, and the mission failed. This was the seventh flight of an H3, and the second failure - the first launch was the other failure.
Ordinarily, when a mission fails the inevitable failure analysis gets carried out and we learn a bit more about what happened. In this case, the day after the launch we got this feedback.
The H3 launched from Tanegashima Space Center on Sunday (Dec. 21) at 8:51 p.m. EST (0151 GMT and 10:51 a.m. local Japan time on Dec. 22), carrying a navigation satellite known as Michibiki 5, or QZS-5, aloft.
"However, the second stage engine’s second ignition failed to start normally and shut down prematurely," officials with the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) said in a statement early Monday morning (Dec. 22). "As a result, QZS-5 could not be put into the planned orbit, and the launch failed."
Here we are just over a month since the failed mission and a new release from JAXA sounds a bit different from the stated, "...the second stage engine’s second ignition failed to start normally and shut down prematurely." As Ars Technica's Stephen Clark put it, “Japan’s H3 rocket found a new way to fail last month, apparently eluding the imaginations of its own designers and engineers.”
Even with all the photos and video captures they have, it isn't entirely clear what happened. The "big picture" set up will be familiar to you if you've watched lots of mission videos. In most launches we can watch, if there's a payload fairing, it stays on until the rocket is well above the thickest part of the atmosphere, well beyond "Max Q" or the highest dynamic pressures on the rocket that come from a combination of air density and speed. Some vehicles seem to drop the booster and start the second (or upper) stage engine(s) before they drop the fairings while others will drop the fairings before Main Engine Cut Off (MECO).
Some of the material is difficult to grasp for a non-Japanese speaker unfamiliar with the subtle intricacies of the H3 rocket’s design. What is clear is that something went wrong when the rocket released its payload shroud. Video beamed back from the rocket’s onboard cameras showed a shower of debris surrounding the satellite, which started wobbling and leaning in the moments after fairing separation. Sensors also detected sudden accelerations around the attachment point connecting the spacecraft with the top of the H3 rocket.
...
The jolt from staging dislodged the satellite from its mooring atop the rocket. Then, the second stage lit its engine and left the satellite in the dust. A rear-facing camera on the upper stage captured a fleeting view of the satellite falling back to Earth. In the briefing package, Japanese space officials wrote that Michibiki 5 fell into the Pacific Ocean in the same impact zone as the H3’s first stage.
Whatever caused the satellite to break free of the rocket damaged more than its attach fitting. Telemetry data downlinked from the H3 showed a pressure drop in the second stage’s liquid hydrogen tank after separation of the payload fairing.
“A decrease in LH2 tank pressure was confirmed almost simultaneously,” officials wrote. A pressurization valve continued to open to restore pressure to the tank, but the pressure did not recover. “It is highly likely that the satellite mounting structure was damaged due to some factor, and as a result, the pressurization piping was damaged.”
In this day of computer assisted drawing and image generation, JAXA presented this stunningly realistic rendering of the damage to the satellite's mounting structure as the payload (blue block on the right) breaks away and starts to fall back to Earth.
Japan's space agency provided this illustration of what happened, just in case
you couldn't visualize it. Credit: JAXA
I really need to work on being less sarcastic.
Whatever caused the satellite to break away led to immediate damage to the upper stage liquid hydrogen fuel tank. Telemetry from the upper stage showed an immediate drop in pressure. A system on board that's supposed to help re-pressurize the second stage turned on but had no effect, indicating damage as shown in the above CAD rendering.
Even with this damage, the second stage engine lost 20 percent of its thrust, but it fired long enough to put the rocket into a low-altitude orbit. The orbit was too low to sustain so the second stage reentered the atmosphere and burned up within a couple of hours.
Technicians mount the H3 rocket’s payload fairing, containing the Michibiki 5 satellite, on top of the launcher’s second stage. Credit: JAXA
JAXA must complete the latest H3 failure investigation in the coming months to clear the rocket to launch the nation’s Martian Moons Exploration (MMX) mission in a narrow planetary launch window that opens in October. MMX is an exciting robotic mission to land on and retrieve samples from the Martian moon Phobos for return to Earth. MMX’s launch was previously set for 2024, but Japan’s space agency delayed it to this year due to earlier problems with the H3 rocket.



























